State Codes and Statutes

Statutes > New-york > Rpt > Article-7 > Title-2 > 744

§  744.    Action  by court in proceedings to review special franchise  assessments.  1.    In  a  proceeding  to  review  a  special  franchise  assessment, upon filing of the answer or upon joinder of issue the court  may take such evidence as it may deem necessary or may appoint a referee  to  take  evidence  and  hear  and determine all questions raised by the  petition and the answer thereto. Notwithstanding any provisions of  this  article  to  the  contrary,  evidence  on the issue of whether a special  franchise  assessment  is  unequal  shall  be  limited  to   the   state  equalization  rate  or special equalization rate used in determining the  final special franchise assessment under review, and  such  equalization  rate or special equalization rate shall be binding and conclusive on the  parties  upon any such issue.  Upon motion of either party the court may  order the place of trial changed to the  county  in  which  the  special  franchise  under review is situated.  The place of trial shall be deemed  changed to the county designated and the papers and proceedings shall be  certified to that county in the manner provided by law in the case of  a  change in the place of trial of an action and all subsequent proceedings  shall  be  had in the county so designated as if the special proceedings  had been originally instituted in that county.    2.  Any objection to the report made pursuant to section  six  hundred  four of this chapter, the complaint made pursuant to section six hundred  ten  of  this  chapter,  the petition or the answer may be raised at the  hearing and the court or referee shall hear and determine the same.  The  attorney general or other counsel shall furnish the petitioner not  less  than thirty days prior to the hearing with a statement of any objections  to  be  raised  to  the  report,  complaint, or petition on the hearing.  Within the same time the petitioner shall furnish the  attorney  general  or  other counsel with a statement of any objections to be raised to the  answer on the hearing.    3.  Either party may appeal directly to the appellate division of  the  supreme  court  from  a  ruling or decision of the court or referee upon  objections raised to the report, complaint, petition or answer  and  the  hearing  may  be  stayed  by  an order of the supreme court pending such  appeal.    4.  Upon application of the attorney general  upon  cause  shown,  the  governor may appoint extraordinary terms of the supreme court to be held  in  any judicial district and designate a justice to preside thereat, to  try special  franchise  cases.    Such  extraordinary  term  shall  have  jurisdiction   over   all   proceedings   involving   special  franchise  assessments arising in any assessing unit within the  judicial  district  for  which  the term is appointed, without regard to the county in which  the term is being held.   Either party  to  a  proceeding  to  review  a  special franchise assessment may at any time bring the proceeding on for  a  hearing  or  trial  before such extraordinary term upon fifteen days'  notice given to the other party either personally or by mail.    5.  A new assessment or correction of an assessment made by  order  of  the court shall have the same force and effect as if it had been so made  by the proper officers within the time prescribed by law for making such  assessment.

State Codes and Statutes

Statutes > New-york > Rpt > Article-7 > Title-2 > 744

§  744.    Action  by court in proceedings to review special franchise  assessments.  1.    In  a  proceeding  to  review  a  special  franchise  assessment, upon filing of the answer or upon joinder of issue the court  may take such evidence as it may deem necessary or may appoint a referee  to  take  evidence  and  hear  and determine all questions raised by the  petition and the answer thereto. Notwithstanding any provisions of  this  article  to  the  contrary,  evidence  on the issue of whether a special  franchise  assessment  is  unequal  shall  be  limited  to   the   state  equalization  rate  or special equalization rate used in determining the  final special franchise assessment under review, and  such  equalization  rate or special equalization rate shall be binding and conclusive on the  parties  upon any such issue.  Upon motion of either party the court may  order the place of trial changed to the  county  in  which  the  special  franchise  under review is situated.  The place of trial shall be deemed  changed to the county designated and the papers and proceedings shall be  certified to that county in the manner provided by law in the case of  a  change in the place of trial of an action and all subsequent proceedings  shall  be  had in the county so designated as if the special proceedings  had been originally instituted in that county.    2.  Any objection to the report made pursuant to section  six  hundred  four of this chapter, the complaint made pursuant to section six hundred  ten  of  this  chapter,  the petition or the answer may be raised at the  hearing and the court or referee shall hear and determine the same.  The  attorney general or other counsel shall furnish the petitioner not  less  than thirty days prior to the hearing with a statement of any objections  to  be  raised  to  the  report,  complaint, or petition on the hearing.  Within the same time the petitioner shall furnish the  attorney  general  or  other counsel with a statement of any objections to be raised to the  answer on the hearing.    3.  Either party may appeal directly to the appellate division of  the  supreme  court  from  a  ruling or decision of the court or referee upon  objections raised to the report, complaint, petition or answer  and  the  hearing  may  be  stayed  by  an order of the supreme court pending such  appeal.    4.  Upon application of the attorney general  upon  cause  shown,  the  governor may appoint extraordinary terms of the supreme court to be held  in  any judicial district and designate a justice to preside thereat, to  try special  franchise  cases.    Such  extraordinary  term  shall  have  jurisdiction   over   all   proceedings   involving   special  franchise  assessments arising in any assessing unit within the  judicial  district  for  which  the term is appointed, without regard to the county in which  the term is being held.   Either party  to  a  proceeding  to  review  a  special franchise assessment may at any time bring the proceeding on for  a  hearing  or  trial  before such extraordinary term upon fifteen days'  notice given to the other party either personally or by mail.    5.  A new assessment or correction of an assessment made by  order  of  the court shall have the same force and effect as if it had been so made  by the proper officers within the time prescribed by law for making such  assessment.

State Codes and Statutes

State Codes and Statutes

Statutes > New-york > Rpt > Article-7 > Title-2 > 744

§  744.    Action  by court in proceedings to review special franchise  assessments.  1.    In  a  proceeding  to  review  a  special  franchise  assessment, upon filing of the answer or upon joinder of issue the court  may take such evidence as it may deem necessary or may appoint a referee  to  take  evidence  and  hear  and determine all questions raised by the  petition and the answer thereto. Notwithstanding any provisions of  this  article  to  the  contrary,  evidence  on the issue of whether a special  franchise  assessment  is  unequal  shall  be  limited  to   the   state  equalization  rate  or special equalization rate used in determining the  final special franchise assessment under review, and  such  equalization  rate or special equalization rate shall be binding and conclusive on the  parties  upon any such issue.  Upon motion of either party the court may  order the place of trial changed to the  county  in  which  the  special  franchise  under review is situated.  The place of trial shall be deemed  changed to the county designated and the papers and proceedings shall be  certified to that county in the manner provided by law in the case of  a  change in the place of trial of an action and all subsequent proceedings  shall  be  had in the county so designated as if the special proceedings  had been originally instituted in that county.    2.  Any objection to the report made pursuant to section  six  hundred  four of this chapter, the complaint made pursuant to section six hundred  ten  of  this  chapter,  the petition or the answer may be raised at the  hearing and the court or referee shall hear and determine the same.  The  attorney general or other counsel shall furnish the petitioner not  less  than thirty days prior to the hearing with a statement of any objections  to  be  raised  to  the  report,  complaint, or petition on the hearing.  Within the same time the petitioner shall furnish the  attorney  general  or  other counsel with a statement of any objections to be raised to the  answer on the hearing.    3.  Either party may appeal directly to the appellate division of  the  supreme  court  from  a  ruling or decision of the court or referee upon  objections raised to the report, complaint, petition or answer  and  the  hearing  may  be  stayed  by  an order of the supreme court pending such  appeal.    4.  Upon application of the attorney general  upon  cause  shown,  the  governor may appoint extraordinary terms of the supreme court to be held  in  any judicial district and designate a justice to preside thereat, to  try special  franchise  cases.    Such  extraordinary  term  shall  have  jurisdiction   over   all   proceedings   involving   special  franchise  assessments arising in any assessing unit within the  judicial  district  for  which  the term is appointed, without regard to the county in which  the term is being held.   Either party  to  a  proceeding  to  review  a  special franchise assessment may at any time bring the proceeding on for  a  hearing  or  trial  before such extraordinary term upon fifteen days'  notice given to the other party either personally or by mail.    5.  A new assessment or correction of an assessment made by  order  of  the court shall have the same force and effect as if it had been so made  by the proper officers within the time prescribed by law for making such  assessment.